Classic Cake Flavors
Carl's most popular cake! Vanilla buttercream and raspberry filling layered between rich vanilla cake.
A decadent and rich chocolate cake, layered with raspberry filling and chocolate buttercream.
Our rich chocolate cake filled and iced with chocolate buttercream.
Lemon cake filled with lemon filling and vanilla buttercream.
Red velvet cake filled with cream cheese icing.
Get any of our Carl's Classic Cake flavors or mix and match to create the perfect cupcake for you!
Mix and Match Cakes and Cupcakes
Create custom cakes, fillings, and icing flavors
not available in cupcake
Specialty Cake Orders
Want a custom cake? All specialty cake orders require a 72-hour notice. Additional decoration fees range from 10.00-50.00+. Add a custom edible image to your cake for only 10.00 (maximum image is 7.5" X 10.5"). Tiered, fondant, and sculpted cakes require a minimum of 7-14 days notice. For additional information, fill out an inquiry form at shop.marketstreetdiner.com/custom-cake. For wedding cakes, go to carlscakes.net/tastings-and-consultations/.